Their own army was shelling them, and their last shot at stopping it was a pigeon.
A&E’s The Lost Battalion is one of my all-time favorite war films. Rick Schroder (yes, the Silver Spoons kid) played Major Charles Whittlesey, mud on his face and pistol in hand, in a smoke-filled French ravine in 1918.
The real story is sooooo much better.
554 New Yorkers went into that ravine. 194 walked out, and getting them out took a quiet Wall Street lawyer, a shot-up pigeon, two pilots, and a Bronx barber playing dead under a German boot.
These are their stories.
Major Charles Whittlesey (played by Rick Schroder)
Whittlesey was a Harvard-trained lawyer, thin and serious, with wire-rimmed glasses. His Williams College classmates nicknamed him “Count” for his stiff manners.
Not your everyday John Wayne war hero.
His men in the 308th Infantry hailed from the tenements of the Lower East Side. Wore the Statue of Liberty on their shoulder patch.
They busted through on October 2 and reached the north slope of the Charlevaux ravine. Units on both sides stalled, and by morning the Germans had closed the gap behind them.
Runners scurried back for help, and the Germans caught or killed them. The food ran out. The only water was a spring at the bottom of the hill, and German snipers watched it.
Grim.
Their own guns opened up.
Mid-afternoon on October 4, shells started falling on the ravine.
American shells.
Shxtfire.
The gunners thought Whittlesey’s men were on the south slope, but they were on the north. By one researcher’s count, at least 30 men died as the hillside heaved.
Around 3 p.m., Whittlesey wrote out a note for his pigeon handler, Private Omer Richards. Richards reached for one of his last two birds. A shell burst close by, and the bird flapped off into the smoke... with no message.
They had one pigeon left.
Below the line: a shot-up pigeon, two pilots who went looking for them and never came back, and a barber from the Bronx who crawled through German lines for help.
Not a paid subscriber? Free subscribers get 3 paid articles a month, so make this one of them.





